A thesis can be written and organized either in the traditional monograph style or the manuscript (article) based style. It cannot be a mixture of the two. Theses must conform to the requirements of Library and Archives Canada. These requirements are listed below.
In either monograph or manuscript format, the thesis must contain methodology, results and scholarly discussion. It must also contain or conform to the following requirements:
1. Title page
- The title of the thesis
- The student’s name and Unit* followed by "McGill University, Montreal"
- The month and year the thesis was submitted
- The following statement: "A thesis submitted to McGill University in partial fulfillment of the requirements of the degree of....”
- The universal copyright notice “©” followed by the student’s name and the year the thesis was submitted
2. A detailed table of contents
3. A brief abstract in both English and French.
- If the language of the thesis is neither English nor French (only allowed for specific language Units) then a third abstract in the language of the thesis is required.
- Among other acknowledgements, the student is required to declare the extent to which assistance (paid or unpaid) has been given by members of staff, fellow students, research assistants, technicians, or others in the collection of materials and data, the design and construction of apparatus, the performance of experiments, the analysis of data, and the preparation of the thesis (including editorial help).
- In addition, it is appropriate to recognize the supervision and advice given by the thesis supervisor(s) and advisors.
5. Contribution to original knowledge
- A doctoral thesis must clearly state the elements of the thesis that are considered original scholarship and distinct contributions to knowledge.
6. Contribution of Authors
- Contributions of the student to each chapter must be explicitly stated.
- Contributions of any co-authors to each chapter must be explicitly stated.
7. An introduction
- Clearly state the rationale and objectives of the research.
8. A comprehensive review of the relevant literature
- The literature review must be in line with disciplinary expectations.
9. Body of the thesis
- Body of the thesis should encompass sections on:
- Research findings
10. A comprehensive scholarly discussion of all the findings
(In case of a manuscript-based thesis the comprehensive discussion should encompass all of the chapters of the thesis and should not be a repetition of the individual chapters.)
11. A final conclusion and summary
- Clearly state how the objectives of the research were met and discuss implications of findings.
12. A thorough bibliography or reference list
Normally, a Master’s thesis does not exceed 100 pages in length. GPS considers 150 pages to be the maximum (including title page, abstracts, table of contents, contribution of authors/preface, acknowledgements, bibliography/reference list, and appendices).
A Doctoral thesis must be as succinct as is consistent with the sound scholarly exposition of the subject under investigation and disciplinary norms. There is no page limit, but unnecessarily long theses are viewed negatively since one of the norms of academic scholarship is concision.
Appendices are useful to present supplementary or raw data, details of methodology (particularly for manuscript-based theses), consent forms, or other information that would detract from the presentation of the research in the main body of the thesis, but would assist readers in their review. All material in appendices will be open to examination.
Script and Page Format
A conventional font, size 12-point, 12 characters per inch must be used. Line spacing must be double or 1.5. Left and right hand margins should be 1 inch.
Positioning of page numbers is optional. Pages with figures or illustrations may be numbered in sequence or left unnumbered. The chosen procedure must be used consistently throughout the thesis. Pagination must be carefully checked for correct sequence and completeness.
Footnotes, references and appendices
- These should conform to a scholarly style appropriate to the discipline.
- Footnotes may be placed at the bottom of the page or as endnotes at the end of each chapter.
- Consistency of formatting for footnotes and references is required throughout the thesis.
- Note: Handbooks such as the MLA or APA handbook may be consulted for formatting styles. These are available at the Reference desk of the McLennan Library.
Figures, illustrations, photographs and digital images
- Figures, tables, graphs, etc., should be positioned according to the publication conventions of the discipline. Charts, graphs, maps, and tables that are larger than the standard page should be avoided unless absolutely necessary. Overlays must be meticulously positioned in the text.
- Where graphs, illustrations, photographs, etc. fill an entire page, these pages can be numbered in sequence or left unnumbered (see Pagination above). Legends or captions accompanying such full-page graphics must be presented on a separate page.
Slides, tapes, etc. are to be avoided if possible and can be included only if the student authorizes the reproduction of the thesis without them.
Manuscript-Based (Article-Based) Theses
As an alternative to the traditional format, a thesis may be presented as a collection of scholarly papers of which the student is the first author or co-first author. A manuscript-based doctoral thesis must include the text of a minimum of two manuscripts published, submitted or to be submitted for publication. Articles must be formatted according to the requirements described below. A manuscript-based Master’s thesis must include the text of one or more manuscripts.
Manuscripts for publication in journals are frequently very concise documents. A thesis, however, is expected to consist of more detailed, scholarly work. A manuscript-based thesis will be evaluated by the examiners as a unified, logically coherent document in the same way a traditional thesis is evaluated. Publication of manuscripts, or acceptance for publication by a peer-reviewed journal, does not guarantee that the thesis will be found acceptable for the degree sought.
A manuscript-based thesis must:
- be presented with uniform font size, line spacing, and margin sizes (see Thesis Format above);
- conform to all other requirements listed under Thesis Components above;
- contain additional text that connects the manuscript(s) in a logical progression from one chapter to the next, producing a cohesive, unitary focus, and documenting a single program of research - the manuscript(s) alone do not constitute the thesis;
- stand as an integrated whole.
For manuscript based thesis, each individual chapter/manuscript should be identical to the published/submitted version of the paper, including the reference list. The only change is with respect to the font/size which should be the same as the one used for the rest of the thesis for consistency and homogeneity reasons. So each chapter represents a full manuscript and has its own reference list.Then at the end of the thesis, you have a master reference list which includes all the other references cited throughout the other sections of the thesis, mostly within the general introduction but also from the general discussion
In the case of multiple-authored articles, the student must be the first author. Multiple-authored articles cannot be used in more than one thesis. In the case of students who have worked collaboratively on projects, it may be preferable for both students to write a traditional format thesis, identifying individual contributions. Consult this page for information on intellectual property and required permissions/waivers.
In the case of co-first authored articles, only one student can use the article in a manuscript-based thesis and must have a written agreement from the other co-first author student(s).
*Unit refers to a department, a division, a school, an institute, or a Faculty/University-wide program.